Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra
Giving Auroville land for purposes other than Auroville is NOT acceptable without the approval of vast majority of residents. These lands were likely donated to Auroville (or purchased using donations) by well-wishers of Auroville like us and it's not OK for the foundation to give it away. It's not their personal property.
Giving bureaucracy power over Auroville is dangerous. Even if Ms. Jayanti Ravi was doing good work until now, she is a bureacrat at end of the day and they are employees of the govt who have to obey govt dictats.
Though I had expressed it strongly, that's my humble opinion. I generally distrust bureaucrats and Auroville wasn't created by Mother to be administered by bureaucrats. Ms Jayanti Ravi may be doing good work but sooner the control reverts to Aurovillians the better.
https://x.com/Shiva_Uvacha/status/1958586039762919513?t=L4hnQRkuny5msc-MhwiHYA&s=19
A trustee or govt appointed administrator, even if they are of pure heart and intent like @JayantiRavi should not give away the property of Auroville. The property - Annapurna farm was bought with donations by devotees of the Mother and Sri Aurobindo and well-wishers of Auroville for explicit purpose of Auroville. It wasn't given by govt for it to be given away to IITs. If those farms were used (or under utilised) by some coterie within Auroville, I hope @JayantiRavi ji fixes its usage and not give it away. At best it can be exchanged for adjacent land of equal value and *not*given away. That is not justifiable in my humble opinion.
One can think of it as temple property. The trustees or the govt appointees cannot give it away for any reason. Similarly their job here is to ensure that it is utilised properly for Auroville and not give it away to IITs.
https://x.com/Shiva_Uvacha/status/1958756077794918615?t=Ber27MRe4RXPax-KtEFAvw&s=19
Can the fact that a small coterie did not utilise the farm properly create a moral or ethical justification to give away Auroville land? It is not government property for govt to take away. It was property bought with donations of well-wishers of Auroville and devotees of Mother and Sri Aurobindo. They need to be treated on par with temple properties, meaning noone can give it away and neither should govt claim it.
As a devotee of thr Mother and a wellwisher and donor of Auroville, this is my sincere and original opinion. I have not listened to any propaganda by anyone on this matter.
If land near to Auroville city is desired, land swap arrangements can and should be worked out. Then the purpose of Auroville would be served better.
With immense respect to @JayantiRavi, and the great work she has done, I want to reiterate that there is no logical, moral or ethical or Spiritual justification for donating Auroville land to IIT or any other purpose. I say *spiritual* justification because no human mind made purpose, including that of IITs is loftier than the purpose of Auroville, which was a creation of Spiritual consciousness.
Are we to believe that IIT has a higher divine purpose than Auroville? Then let entire Auroville be donated to IIT.
To my intuition this seems an act against the Will of the Mother and not justifiable.
https://x.com/Shiva_Uvacha/status/1958772994572247138?t=y6AkXb1PvKsM-Ku-XWuHjw&s=19
I am all for ridding Auroville and the Annapurna farm from the clutches of some small coterie of vested interests. But citing that as a reason to donate Auroville land is not justifiable. It would be like burning down the house to get rid of rat problem. @JayantiRavi
All property of Auroville belongs to the Divine. Giving it away for any purpose other than Divine work it was intended for is to work against the Will of the Divine. Our job in any capacity small or big is to do our best to ensure that it is used in a better way for Auroville. Auroville land was bought with donations of devotees and well-wishers who donated specifically for the Mother's work (and / or Auroville), not for any IITs.
From a ethical perspectives, it is very similar to how politicians swallow temple property and courts have explicitly prohibited using temple lands for any purpose including building colleges. Not under control of the said temple. The same logic should apply here.
https://x.com/Shiva_Uvacha/status/1958775227510591845?t=fSIADmdZHEG6D8eT-AXhmA&s=19
Dear @JayantiRavi ma'am, my concern is based on the reports that the ownership of the land would be gifted to IIT-M. I am hoping that it is only half-truth and full truth will set our minds at ease.
For example, if the land ownership were to remain with Auroville and the sustainability center is to be (co-)managed by qualified Aurovillians in collaboration with IIT-M researchers, then one would expect that an overwhelming majority well-wishers, volunteers of Auroville, devotees of the Mother and Sri Aurobindo and donors to Auroville would be very supportive. It would be a great milestone on the way of realising Auroville vision.
Unlike other institutions of repute like IITs founded with high intentions but in mental consciousness, Auroville was created with the highest Divine consciousness and Force to serve as a symbolic battleground to birth a new consciousness. So Auroville is bound to face all problems of the world in a symbolic way and will have to find solutions based in a higher consciousness. You have been blessed to be a warrior of light in fighting the good fight so far.
Hence my humble request to not view any Auroville property in a purely utilitarian manner as bureaucrats are wont to do, but view it in conjunction with the pure, high and mighty Spiritual vision and Force behind it. Any experienced sadhak can sense that the spiritual force in Matrimandir is unparalleld in the world. Not even the famous Saktipeeths can be compared to Matrimandir. There is a live cosmic Spiritual Force working on the world through Auroville. Even a failed experiment done in Auroville will have a far reaching impact in human consciousness based thanks to Force behind its creation as a symbolic embryo of new consciousness for the Earth.
What does that mean in practical things? In my humble view, that means Auroville would need to retain ownership of its properties (or exchange them for nearby properties of equal value if that would serve Auroville's purpose better) as no other man made institution will have such highest Spiritual force behind it.
If there is to be a sustainability center, it should be under the aegis of Auroville (with perpetual land ownership residing with Auroville) and run or co-run by competent Auroville volunteers in collaboration with experts from IIT-M, etc., and Auroville Foundation retained as the binding authority on any future decisioning regarding the sustainability center.
It is my sincere submission that Auroville land / assets are not gifted away for other human endeavours however high and expedient they may look from an utilitarian perspective.
Thank you for your time and I hope you get to atleast read this post and continue to be guided by the Mother's light in your decisions.
CC: @GoutamGhosal3
https://x.com/Shiva_Uvacha/status/1958800425500778827?t=giUimUsEmtN16NaV4RJOHA&s=19